Review · COLOMBIA
From San Andrés: Speedboat Tour to Johnny Cay Island
Johnny Cay is the main attraction here: a small, sunny island reached by a quick 20-minute speedboat ride from San Andrés. You get clear water, beach time, marine life, restaurants, and the chance to see its famous iguanas without committing a full day to several keys.
I like that the entrance tax and round-trip transport are included in the $33 price. I also like the simple schedule, with roughly three and a half hours on the cay instead of a packed route that rushes you from stop to stop. The main concern is organization. Several bookings recorded late departures, confusion at the dock, and trouble arranging the return boat, so this trip suits flexible people more than anyone on a tight schedule.
Key points to know before booking

- Johnny Cay is the only stop: You spend about 3.5 hours on the island, with swimming, sightseeing, snorkeling, and free time.
- The boat ride takes 20 minutes each way: The transfer is short, but the sea crossing can still feel active.
- Food is available but not included: Restaurants operate on the cay, yet you pay separately, and the activity information says not to bring food or drinks.
- Snorkeling equipment is extra: Bring or arrange your own equipment if you want more than swimming and looking from shore.
- Anthony was singled out for good service: He and the cay staff were the bright spot in an otherwise uneven operation.
- The full-day alternative covers more: A longer excursion adds the Aquarium, Mangroves, and Bay Tour to Johnny Cay.
A short boat ride to San Andrés’s best-known cay

Johnny Cay gives you a classic Caribbean day without a long transfer. From the meeting point on Av. Newball, the speedboat takes about 20 minutes to reach the island. That short ride leaves most of your day for the cay itself, though the wait before departure can affect how much time you actually get there.
The island is known for its bright water and beaches, but the appeal is not only the shoreline. You can swim, watch marine life, look for iguanas, and sit down for food or a drink at one of the island restaurants. The setting is made for a sunny break from San Andrés, especially if you want a beach day with a clear beginning and end.
This is a single-site trip, which is both its strength and its limit. You will not spend the day changing boats or making several short stops. On the other hand, you will not see the Aquarium, mangroves, or the bay on this outing.
More speedboat tours around the world:
- Portimão: Benagil Caves Speed Boat Tour with Sunset Option
★ 4.8 · 11,663 reviews - Dubai: Marina, Atlantis, Palm & Burj Al Arab Speedboat Tour
★ 4.8 · 11,595 reviews - Blue cave, Mamma Mia and Hvar, 5 islands speedboat tour
★ 5.0 · 7,150 reviews
Meeting at Martinez Renta Autos

You meet at Martinez Renta Autos on Av. Newball, in front of the Sunrise Beach Hotel. The listed starting location is Martinez Renta Autos, and the company name is useful to have ready when you arrive. The stated finish is at Cl. 2 #2-160 in San Andrés.
The practical issue is the departure process. The current score for the experience is 3.6 out of 5 from six ratings, and the weakest comments focus on coordination rather than the island. One person reported that the boat did not leave at the announced time and that staff only began sorting out passengers at the dock. Another described confusion over who was responsible for the outbound transfer and difficulty getting a boat back.
I would arrive with extra time and keep your booking details available. Ask clearly where you should wait, which boat is yours, and what the return arrangement is before you leave the dock. That is not glamorous advice, but it can prevent a pleasant island visit from ending with an unnecessary scramble.
Spanish is the stated language for the host or greeter. If you need detailed questions answered in another language, arrange that before booking rather than assuming it will be available on site.
The 20-minute speedboat crossing

The ride to Johnny Cay takes about 20 minutes, followed by another 20 minutes back to San Andrés. In theory, that makes the transport efficient. You spend only about 40 minutes of the day moving between the island and the main island, leaving a long break for swimming and sightseeing.
The ride is part of the experience, but it is still transport rather than a guided cruise. No guide for a tour of the keys is included, and no snorkeling guide is included. You should book this with the expectation of getting to Johnny Cay, not of receiving a running explanation of the surrounding waters or islands.
The return boat matters just as much as the first crossing. Because the reported problems center on the trip home, confirm the pickup point and departure plan while you are still at the cay. If staff give you a meeting time, keep it in mind and do not assume the return will arrange itself.
Three and a half hours on Johnny Cay
The main break lasts about 3.5 hours. That is enough time for a relaxed visit, but it is not a full day at the beach. You can divide the time among swimming, walking around, looking for marine life, eating, and sitting in the shade or breeze if a suitable place is available.
The water is the star. The activity is designed around clear water and a sunny day, so swimmers who want a simple sea break will get the most from it. You can also snorkel, but the price does not include equipment or a person to guide you. Bring only what is permitted and confirm equipment arrangements before leaving San Andrés.
The island also has a memorable local feature: iguanas. You may see them during your visit, along with marine species in their natural setting. That adds more interest than a beach stop where the only activity is lying in the sun. Still, the experience does not promise a wildlife tour, and sightings are not presented as guaranteed.
You can eat and drink at island restaurants, but neither food nor drinks are part of the $33 price. The information also says food and drinks are not allowed, so do not plan to pack a picnic or a cooler. Budget separately for anything you buy on Johnny Cay.
Same coastline, a different hull:
- Portimão: Benagil Sea Caves Speedboat Adventure Tour
★ 4.8 · 6,546 reviews - Albufeira: Benagil Caves & Dolphin Watching Speed Boat Tour
★ 4.6 · 6,316 reviews - Captain Bob Speed Boat, Snorkeling, Beach Tour & Lunch St Maarten
★ 5.0 · 4,336 reviews - Rhodes: Speedboat Trip to Symi with Free Time to Explore
★ 4.5 · 4,265 reviews
What the $33 price really covers

At $33 per person, the price is easy to understand: you are paying for the boat ride in both directions and the entrance tax to Johnny Cay. That is fair value if you mainly want access to the island and plan to spend your time swimming or relaxing.
The price becomes less attractive if you expect a guided snorkeling session, equipment, meals, or several island stops. None of those are included. You may also spend more at the cay if you buy food and drinks, so treat $33 as the starting cost of the outing rather than your complete beach-day budget.
The simple format can be a benefit. You are not paying for activities you may not use, and you have freedom during the 3.5-hour break. But that freedom comes with less support. The host is Spanish-speaking, and the activity does not include a guide to explain the keys or lead you through the water.
For someone already staying near San Andrés and looking for a short island outing, the value is solid if the boat operation runs on time. For anyone who wants a polished, tightly managed day, the organization concerns are worth taking seriously.
The organization issue you should weigh

The main weakness is not Johnny Cay itself. It is the handling of the transfers. Two direct accounts describe late or unclear departures, and one describes uncertainty about the return ride. Those are practical problems because a boat trip has fewer easy alternatives than a land excursion.
The positive point is that one account specifically called Anthony exceptional and also praised the rest of the cay staff. That suggests the on-island service may feel better than the dockside coordination. I would look for Anthony or ask for help from the cay staff if you need assistance once you arrive, but I would not assume that one helpful person represents every part of the operation.
The experience currently carries a mixed score of 3.6 out of 5. That number is not a reason to reject the trip outright, but it tells you to set realistic expectations. You are choosing a basic transfer to a beautiful island, not a carefully managed small-group tour.
Is Johnny Cay too commercial for you?

Johnny Cay is described as highly commercialized in one account, with the suggestion that nearby beaches can feel more relaxed and free of the same sales pressure or crowding. That criticism matters if your ideal Caribbean day means quiet sand, few services, and plenty of personal space.
The restaurants are useful if you want lunch or a drink without carrying supplies. They also make the island feel less remote and more developed. Some people will see that as convenient. Others will feel it takes away from the natural setting.
I would choose Johnny Cay if you want the island that is most directly associated with San Andrés and you enjoy having services close by. I would think twice if you dislike commercial beach areas or want a private-feeling shore. The outing gives you a recognizable attraction, not an untouched island experience.
Who will enjoy this half-day island outing?
This trip fits you best if you want:
- A quick boat ride rather than a long day at sea
- Several hours of swimming and beach time
- Clear water and the chance to see marine life
- A simple outing with one main destination
- The freedom to choose your own pace once you arrive
- A low headline price that covers entry and transport
It is less suitable if you need dependable minute-by-minute timing, a guided snorkeling session, or a quiet beach with little commercial activity. It is also not suitable for children under three, pregnant women, or people with mobility impairments. Baby carriages are not allowed.
The supplied information does not give a group size, so you should not book this expecting a private boat. It also does not describe a formal guided commentary. Think of it as transport plus free time on Johnny Cay.
Johnny Cay or the full-day keys excursion?

If Johnny Cay is your only priority, this shorter trip keeps the plan simple. You get the cay, its water, its restaurants, its marine life, and its iguanas without giving up a whole day to a longer route.
If you want a fuller picture of the waters around San Andrés, the alternative full-day excursion adds the Aquarium, Mangroves, and Bay Tour along with Johnny Cay. That option makes more sense for a first visit when you want several types of scenery and activities in one day.
The tradeoff is time and focus. The Johnny Cay trip gives you one island and about 3.5 hours there. The full-day route offers more variety, but a fuller schedule can mean less unhurried time at any one stop. Choose based on your own priority: a focused beach break or a broader day among the keys.
Booking flexibility and practical limits
You can cancel up to 24 hours in advance for a full refund, and the reserve-now, pay-later option lets you hold a place without paying immediately. That helps if your plans are still shifting, but you should still check the available starting time for your chosen date.
The activity is valid for one day, and the schedule depends on availability. Since timing and dock organization are the main concern, check the meeting details carefully and leave room in your day after the return. I would avoid booking an airport transfer, dinner reservation, or other fixed appointment too close to the listed finish.
Do not count on included snorkeling gear, meals, drinks, or a guide. The $33 covers the entrance tax and round-trip transport. Everything else should be treated as a separate arrangement or expense.
Should you book this Johnny Cay trip?
Book it if you want a straightforward, affordable way to reach Johnny Cay and you are happy to handle your own time on the island. The clear water, iguanas, marine life, restaurants, and three-and-a-half-hour break make a good match for a relaxed beach day.
Skip it if you need precise departure times, strong guidance, or a quieter setting. The reported confusion at the dock and on the return boat is a real concern, not a minor detail. If you book, arrive early, confirm both boat arrangements, and keep your schedule loose.
For the best balance, choose this outing when Johnny Cay itself is the goal. Choose the full-day keys tour when you want the Aquarium, Mangroves, and Bay Tour as well. The island may be commercial, but the water and the easy access are the reason this remains a tempting choice.
FAQ
Where do I meet for the Johnny Cay tour?
Meet at Martinez Renta Autos on Av. Newball, in front of the Sunrise Beach Hotel, on San Andrés Island.
How long is the speedboat ride to Johnny Cay?
The speedboat takes about 20 minutes each way.
How much time do I get on Johnny Cay?
The scheduled break on the island is about 3.5 hours, including free time, swimming, snorkeling, sightseeing, and marine life viewing.
Is food or drink included?
No. Food and drinks are not included, although restaurants are available on Johnny Cay. The activity information also says food and drinks are not allowed to be brought along.
Is snorkeling equipment provided?
No. Snorkeling equipment is not included, and the tour does not provide a guide to lead snorkeling or tour the keys.
Can I cancel for a refund?
Yes. You can cancel up to 24 hours in advance for a full refund. The reserve-now, pay-later option is also available.
Newly added boat runs around the world
- Speed Boat Trip: Kotor Bay attraction , Blue Cave and beach time★ 5.0 · 63 reviews
- Speedboat Tour to Lady of the Rock, Mamula and Blue Cave Swim★ 5.0 · 132 reviews
- Kotor: Boka Bay Grand Explorer: 6.5-Hour Private Speedboat Tour★ 5.0 · 2 reviews
- Experience Speedboat Tours in Kotor, Montenegro★ 5.0 · 5 reviews
- Blue Cave 3 hours PRIVATE tour with modern speedboat★ 5.0 · 29 reviews
- Blue Cave, Lady of the Rocks and Kotor Bay SpeedBoat Tour 3H★ 5.0 · 70 reviews
- Boka Bay tour by car or speedboat (Private tour)★ 5.0 · 4 reviews
- Blue Cave and Our Lady of the Rocks – 3h Private Speedboat Tour★ 5.0 · 13 reviews
Colombia Speedboat Tours, side by side.

Open Bar Sunset Cruise in Catamaran or Speedboat (Best Deal)
Read our review →
San Andres: Private San Andres Bay Tour by Luxury Speedboat
Read our review →
Cartagena: All-Inclusive Rosario Islands Speedboat Tour
Read our review →
Cartagena: Speed Boat Party on the Bay with open bar
Read our review →
Cartagena: Playa Blanca BARU by speedboat with lunch
Read our review →
Cartagena: Visit 4 islands in a speedboat + plankton!
Read our review →Other lists this boat trip sits in

